Tellers An American Chophouse Menu (Update 2025)
At Tellers An American Chophouse, located in Islip, NY, customers rave about the perfection of every steak on the menu. The porterhouse for two, filet, and NY strip with blue cheese are standout choices, along with sides like the burnt broccoli and decadent desserts like Tiramisu and cheesecake. The restaurant's elegant atmosphere, attentive service, and extensive wine list create a memorable dining experience. Special features include a unique dining area inside a transformed bank vault, offering a mix of old-world charm and modern sophistication. The restaurant is ideal for special occasions and gathering with friends, providing a swanky and luxurious setting. Overall, Tellers offers top-notch dishes, impeccable service, and a stylish ambiance that is perfect for creating lasting memories.
Must Have
Tellers Duck Fat Fries
Housemade ketchup and mustard dipping sauces
Sesame-Potato Loaf
Black truffle butter, sea salt
Beef Tartare
Mustard, capers, anchovy, parmesan, naan
Black Pepper Bacon
Thick cut, house-cured, spicy-sweet horseradish glaze
Jumbo Lump Crabcake
Caper gribiche
Shrimp & Lobster Wontons
Pan-seared, hoisin glaze, miso-mustard
Tellers Baked Clams ()
Tellers special stuffing
Crispy Calamari
Cherry peppers, san marzano tomato sauce
Burrata
Citrus & stone fruit, pistachios, cherry pepper honey sauce
Appetizers
Raw Bar
Clams On The Half Shell
Fresh Colossal Crabmeat
oz serving
Shrimp Cocktail
shrimp, cocktail sauce
Tellers Plateau
Serves -, seasonal raw bar tower
Kumamoto
Puget sound, washington
Blue Point
Long island sound, new york
Oysters
Soups & Salads
Lobster Bisque
Chive creme fraiche
Baby Wedge Salad
Roquefort dressing, bacon, tomato, red onion
Caesar Salad
Julienne romaine, breadcrumb, parmesan
Apple Pecan Salad
Arugula, candied pecans, gorgonzola, balsamic vinaigrette
Chopped Vegetable Salad
Haricots verts, snap peas, mushrooms, corn, red onion, pecorino toscano, sherry vinaigrette
Petite Filet Mignon
Filet Mignon
Skirt Steak
Miso marinade
Tellers Delmonico
Truffle butter sauce, crispy onions
Bone-In USDA Prime Cowgirl Ribeye
Bone marrow butter
Classic Tellers
USDA Prime, Day Dry Aged
Boneless NY Strip
Porterhouse For Or
Tellers Signature Ribeye
Pepper-Crusted Kansas City Strip
oz USDA prime, bone-in NY strip, cracked black pepper crusted, au poivre sauce
Herb-Roasted Half Chicken
Grafton cheddar whipped potato, bacon, braised lacinato kale, verjus gravy
Braised Dinosaur Bone
Marinated bone-in beef short rib, cabbage slaw, corn on the cobb, chive oil
Filet Mignon Wellington
Puff pastry, mushroom duxelles, brie fondue, bordelaise
Meat & Poultry
Seafood
Scottish Salmon
Dirty chorizo black rice, red pepper cream sauce, broccolini
Long Island Flounder Oreganata
Herb breadcrumb, grilled lemon, sauteed spinach
Steamed Lobsters
Starting at two pounds and up
Housemade Tater Tots
Gruyere cheese, horseradish cream
Creamed Spinach
Blistered Green Beans With Shishito Peppers & Almonds
Roasted Cremini Mushrooms
Jumbo Asparagus Grilled/Steamed
Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Applewood Smoked Bacon
Burnt Broccoli
Five Cheese "Mac"
Scalloped Parmesan Potatoes
Whipped Potato
French Fries
Loaded Lb Baked Potato
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Four cheese bechamel, lobster, cavatappi pasta, oreganata breadcrumbs
Accessories
Enhancements
Truffled Parmesan Crust
Au Poivre
Bearnaise
Blackened
Hot Cherry Peppers
Shrimp Scampi
Bleu Cheese
Broiled Lobster Tail
Bone Marrow Butter
Striped Bass
Blood orange & asparagus salad, white balsamic gastrique
Snake River Farms American Wagyu Top Sirloin
Black garlic compound butter
Entrees
Appetizer Choices
Baby Wedge Salad
Black Pepper Bacon
Apple Pecan Salad
Tellers "Black Label" Burger
Scottish Salmon
Filet Tips Diane
Old World Pastrami Sandwich
Chicken Paillard
Chopped Steak Salad
$ supplement